Diagnostic Code 5258: Knee. Dislocated Semilunar Cartilage (Meniscus) Rating Criteria
- CFR section
- 38 CFR § 4.71a
- Rating range
- 20%
- Rating levels
- 1
- Body system
- Musculoskeletal system
The VA rates Knee. Dislocated Semilunar Cartilage (Meniscus) under diagnostic code 5258 in 38 CFR § 4.71a. The table below is the full set of rating criteria, from the schedule itself, with the evidence factors raters look for at each level.
DC 5258 rating criteria
| Rating | Criteria |
|---|---|
| 20% | Cartilage, semilunar, dislocated, with frequent episodes of "locking," pain, and effusion into the joint What raters look forfrequent locking; pain; effusion into the joint |
DC 5258 rating appeals at the Board
The Board of Veterans' Appeals issued 1,519 rulings on higher ratings, reductions and severance under diagnostic code 5258 from 2021 to 2026. It granted 64.0%, denied 25.1% and sent 10.9% back for more work. One appeal can contain more than one ruling.
By the rating the Board's order named
Only orders that state a rating percentage with a date are counted. An order denying a rating "in excess of 50 percent" names the existing rating; a grant may name the rating awarded. These are not all ratings veterans requested.
| Rating the order named | Decided rulings | Granted |
|---|---|---|
| 20 percent | 469 | 74.4% |
Recorded exam issues in remanded DC 5258 rulings
Percentages use all 166 rating rulings under this code the Board remanded, 2021 to 2026. Some rulings have no recorded exam classification, and small categories are not shown, so these rows need not total 100 percent.
- The VA exam or opinion was not adequate78.9%
- No exam problem recorded10.2%
- The exam was out of date or the condition had worsened7.2%
Method: Claim Raven read each ruling in every Board decision stored for 2021 to 2026 and counted it under this code when the decision named DC 5258 for a rating question. These results cover only rulings with an identified diagnostic code and may not represent rulings where no code was stated. Granted includes partial grants; dismissed and withdrawn rulings are left out. These are outcomes within appeals, not first decisions, and not your personal odds.
Condition guide
The rating criteria are only part of the picture for Knee. The Knee condition page covers service connection, common evidence problems, secondary conditions, and Board outcome patterns in depth.
What happens to Knee appeals at the Board
Claim Raven's analysis of 107,856 decided Board of Veterans' Appeals rulings on Knee, 2021 to 2026. The Knee condition page has the full breakdown, including which evidence types are associated with better outcomes.
Method: each ruling's outcome is read from the order in the Board's published decision and rolled up as granted (including partial grants), denied, or remanded, leaving out dismissals and withdrawals. The data codes the condition the Board ruled on, not the diagnostic code, so these numbers describe Knee appeals generally rather than DC 5258 specifically. The DC 5258 section above counts this code's own rating appeals. Board outcomes describe appealed claims, not initial decisions.
Frequently asked questions
What is VA diagnostic code 5258?
Diagnostic code 5258 is the VA rating schedule entry for Knee. Dislocated Semilunar Cartilage (Meniscus), found in 38 CFR § 4.71a. The VA assigns this code when it rates the condition and applies the criteria listed on this page.
What ratings are possible under DC 5258?
DC 5258 provides ratings of 20%. The percentage depends on which criteria your medical evidence documents, not on the diagnosis alone.
What does the highest rating under DC 5258 require?
The 20% rating for Knee. Dislocated Semilunar Cartilage requires: Cartilage, semilunar, dislocated, with frequent episodes of "locking," pain, and effusion into the joint.
How often does the Board grant a higher rating under DC 5258?
In 1,503 decided Board of Veterans' Appeals rulings on a higher rating under DC 5258 from 2021 to 2026, 63.6% were granted, 25.3% denied and 11.0% sent back for more work. These are appeal outcomes, not your personal odds.
Free help filing a claim
An accredited veterans service officer (VSO) can file your claim and represent you at no cost. Find a VSO office near you, with phone numbers and addresses in all 50 states and DC.