On this page
- TL;DR
- Pes cavus VA rating criteria (DC 5278)
- How to prove pes cavus is service connected
- Pes cavus with hammer toes, metatarsalgia and other foot ratings
- Conditions secondary to pes cavus
- The pes cavus C&P exam
- Why VA denies pes cavus claims
- Questions veterans ask about pes cavus
- Is pes cavus a VA disability?
- Can high arches that existed before service be service connected?
- What is the highest VA rating for pes cavus?
- Can I get separate ratings for pes cavus and hammer toes?
- Does the bilateral factor apply to a bilateral pes cavus rating?
- Can pes cavus cause other conditions VA will rate?
- Bottom Line
- Related Conditions
Everyone knows flat feet are ratable. Fewer veterans know the opposite deformity has its own code, with the same top ratings. Pes cavus, acquired claw foot, is rated under DC 5278 in 38 CFR § 4.71a at four levels: 0 percent for slight, 10 percent for one foot or both, 30 percent bilateral or 20 percent unilateral, and 50 percent bilateral or 30 percent unilateral. The criteria are anatomical: dropped forefoot with contracted fascia and hammer toes at the top, down to a slight level at the bottom that the code does not define further.
The rating side is straightforward. The service-connection side requires more care because 38 CFR § 4.57 describes pes cavus as a typically congenital or juvenile disease and says service connection is not in order without trauma or other definite evidence of aggravation. When the condition pre-existed service, the record must show the legally required aggravation rather than natural progression. When a service-connected neurological condition drives an acquired deformity, secondary service connection may apply. Trauma in service is another possible lane. This page walks through the rating criteria, how to prove service connection, the same-foot rules, the conditions cavus feet lead to, the C&P exam, and why VA denies these claims.
TL;DR
- Pes cavus (acquired claw foot) is rated under DC 5278 (38 CFR § 4.71a): 50% bilateral or 30% unilateral at the top level, 30% bilateral or 20% unilateral at the next, 10% for one foot or both, and 0% for slight.
- The levels are anatomical: hammer toes, dropped forefoot, contracted plantar fascia, ankle dorsiflexion limits, callosities, and varus deformity decide the level.
- Section 4.57 calls pes cavus a typically congenital or juvenile disease and requires trauma or other definite evidence of aggravation for service connection. Because it is a disease rather than a defect, aggravation can be service connected (VAOPGCPREC 82-90), and §§ 3.304(b) and 3.306 supply the presumptions of soundness and aggravation.
- An acquired deformity caused or aggravated by a service-connected neurological condition may be claimed secondarily under 38 CFR § 3.310, with supporting medical evidence.
- Same-foot bars: a claw foot rating cannot combine with hammer toe (DC 5282) or hallux rigidus (DC 5281) ratings on the same foot, and a separate metatarsalgia rating has to clear the overlap with the cavus criteria's own metatarsal-head tenderness.
- Pes cavus is the mirror of flat feet (DC 5276): opposite deformity, separate code, same rating amounts, and the two do not describe the same foot.
- Cavus feet load the forefoot and destabilize the ankle, feeding metatarsalgia, plantar fascia tightness, and ankle sprain chains; secondary relationships need their own evidence.
- Across 388 decided Board rulings on pes cavus from 2021 to 2026, 25.8% were granted, 30.7% denied and 43.6% remanded. The grant rate is 1.1 points above the Board-wide 24.7%.
Pes cavus VA rating criteria (DC 5278)
The current criteria, level by level, read as follows.
5278 Claw foot (pes cavus), acquired: Marked contraction of plantar fascia with dropped forefoot, all toes hammer toes, very painful callosities, marked varus deformity: 50% bilateral, 30% unilateral All toes tending to dorsiflexion, limitation of dorsiflexion at ankle to right angle, shortened plantar fascia, and marked tenderness under metatarsal heads: 30% bilateral, 20% unilateral Great toe dorsiflexed, some limitation of dorsiflexion at ankle, definite tenderness under metatarsal heads: 10% bilateral, 10% unilateral Slight: 0%
Three properties stand out. First, the code names only the bottom level ("slight"); this page uses moderate, severe and pronounced for the other three as shorthand, borrowed from the flatfoot code next door. Second, the code prices one foot and both feet separately inside itself, so one 50 percent rating covers both feet, not two separate ratings. The bilateral factor in 38 CFR § 4.26 can still apply, but for a code that gives one evaluation for a bilateral condition, VA's manual applies it only when you also have an independently ratable condition of one of your legs, or of both arms (M21-1 V.iv.1.C.4.b). Third, the levels are not symptom-severity words, they are anatomical findings: toe position, ankle dorsiflexion, fascial shortening, metatarsal-head tenderness, callosities, varus deformity. The exam that documents the anatomy is the exam that sets the level.
For orientation against the mirror code: acquired flatfoot (DC 5276) pays the same amounts at every level, 50 percent bilateral and 30 unilateral at the top, 30 and 20 next, 10 for one foot or both, and 0 at the bottom. It describes its levels differently, with pronation, tenderness, spasm, swelling, callosities and response to orthopedic shoes or appliances. The two codes are structural opposites with identical pricing.
What each level means in plain language
Slight (0%): the code lists this level only as "slight," with no further criteria. Service connected but noncompensable.
Moderate (10% for one foot or both): the great toe dorsiflexes, some ankle dorsiflexion limitation appears, and there is definite tenderness under the metatarsal heads. The forefoot is starting to pay for the arch.
Severe (30% bilateral, 20% unilateral): all toes tend toward dorsiflexion (the claw pattern), ankle dorsiflexion is limited to a right angle, the plantar fascia has shortened, and metatarsal-head tenderness is marked. The foot is now structurally deforming, not just high.
Pronounced (50% bilateral, 30% unilateral): the full picture, with marked fascial contraction and dropped forefoot, every toe a hammer toe, very painful callosities, and marked varus deformity. It is the only level that pays more than 30 percent, and only when both feet qualify.
How to prove pes cavus is service connected
Pes cavus has its own service connection rule. Section 4.57 says that "in the absence of trauma or other definite evidence of aggravation, service connection is not in order for pes cavus which is a typically congenital or juvenile disease." The medical picture fits: the deformity typically begins before puberty, and the most common cause is an inherited neuropathy, Charcot-Marie-Tooth disease being the most common type (Seaman, StatPearls, 2026). About two-thirds of patients have an underlying neurological diagnosis (Eleswarapu, Pediatric Annals, 2016). That leaves three lanes.
Pes cavus that existed before service: aggravation
Because § 4.57 calls pes cavus a disease, not a defect, aggravation can be service connected. VA's General Counsel held that service connection may be granted for diseases, but not defects, of congenital, developmental or familial origin, and pointed to § 4.57's pes cavus rule as an example (VAOPGCPREC 82-90). Two presumptions then decide who has to prove what.
If pes cavus was not noted on your entrance exam, you are presumed sound at entry. VA can rebut that only with clear and unmistakable evidence that the condition existed before service and was not aggravated by it (38 CFR § 3.304(b)). Only conditions recorded in the examination report count as noted; a history of the condition recorded at entry is weighed with the other evidence but is not a notation.
If pes cavus was noted at entry, 38 CFR § 3.306 presumes aggravation when the condition increased in severity during service, unless clear and unmistakable evidence shows the increase was due to the natural progress of the disease. Aggravation is not conceded if the evidence from before, during and after service shows no increase in severity during service.
Either way, the evidence should compare the foot at entry, during service, and after service, and show what changed in the foot itself: toe position, callosities, ankle motion, profiles or treatment.
Pes cavus secondary to a neurological condition
Muscle imbalance is the usual engine of a neurological cavus foot: weaker muscles are overpowered by stronger ones, and the arch rises (Seaman 2026). When the driver is service connected, such as peripheral neuropathy or a spinal cord condition, secondary service connection under 38 CFR § 3.310 may apply if the medical evidence connects the neurological condition to the foot mechanics. The opinion has to address both routes: that the service-connected condition caused the cavus foot, or aggravated it, meaning it would be less severe but for that condition. An opinion that skips aggravation is inadequate (El-Amin v. Shinseki, 26 Vet. App. 136 (2013)). Because so many cavus feet have a neurological cause, a cavus foot also warrants a neurological examination for an underlying cause (Akoh, Foot and Ankle Clinics, 2019).
Pes cavus from an injury in service
The rarer direct case is trauma, which § 4.57 itself names. A cavus deformity driven by the hindfoot is commonly the result of trauma, including malunited ankle (pilon), talar neck or calcaneal fractures and long-standing ankle instability (Seaman 2026). Documented trauma plus documented deformity plus time, with the same anatomical criteria at the end.
None of these is automatic, and the aggravation lane especially turns on the quality of the entry-versus-current comparison.
Pes cavus with hammer toes, metatarsalgia and other foot ratings
The foot schedule polices double-counting deformity by deformity. DC 5281 says hallux rigidus is "not to be combined with claw foot ratings," and DC 5282 pays its 10 percent for hammer toes of all toes on one foot only "without claw foot." The 5278 criteria already price toe dorsiflexion and hammering at the two top levels, so the toe codes are absorbed (38 CFR § 4.14 bars counting the same manifestation twice anyway).
The other neighbors fall under VA's general foot rule: when the cause of the symptoms cannot be separated, raters assign one evaluation for the predominant symptoms; when it can, separate evaluations are allowed as long as § 4.14 is not violated (M21-1 V.iii.1.B.5.c). The manual has no pes cavus pairing rule like its flat feet rules, and two overlaps matter in practice. Every compensable level of DC 5278 lists tenderness under the metatarsal heads, which is exactly where metatarsalgia (DC 5279) hurts, so a separate metatarsalgia rating needs findings the cavus rating does not already count. And the top two levels list a shortened or contracted plantar fascia, so a separate plantar fasciitis (DC 5269) rating needs heel findings the examiner separates from the cavus findings.
The mirror-code boundary runs the other way: pes cavus and pes planus describe opposite deformities of the arch, so a single foot is one or the other.
Conditions secondary to pes cavus
The biomechanics are the reason this section exists. A cavus foot overloads the metatarsal heads and the outer border of the foot, and patients often present with pain there, an unstable gait or frequent ankle sprains (Eleswarapu 2016). The soft tissues on the outside of the ankle can be overloaded during gait, causing ankle instability, and the tight plantar fascia absorbs shock poorly (Seaman 2026). In the subtle form of the deformity, ankle instability, peroneal tendon tears and stress fractures of the outer metatarsals are common problems (Visser, Clinics in Podiatric Medicine and Surgery, 2021). In one prospective study of military recruits, femoral and tibial stress fractures were more common in feet with high arches (Simkin, Foot and Ankle, 1989).
These are recognized associations, useful for understanding which conditions tend to travel together, and every one of them needs its own diagnosis, its own evidence, and its own nexus for a secondary claim, with an opinion that addresses both causation and aggravation. Nothing in this section is a promise that a cavus foot produces any of them in a given veteran. The ankle page covers instability claims.
The pes cavus C&P exam
VA's public form for this exam is the Foot Conditions, Including Flatfoot (Pes Planus) DBQ, and its acquired pes cavus section reads like the criteria. For each side it asks about the toes (great toe dorsiflexed, all toes tending to dorsiflexion, all toes hammer toes), tenderness under the metatarsal heads (definite or marked) and very painful callosities, the plantar fascia (shortened, or marked contraction with dropped forefoot), and ankle dorsiflexion and varus deformity. Each box maps to a level. What strengthens the file is the record behind the exam.
- Serial podiatry documentation of progression: toe changes, callosities, fitting failures, orthotic prescriptions over years.
- Weight-bearing imaging showing the arch structure; a lateral weight-bearing X-ray confirms the diagnosis (Eleswarapu 2016). Add the neurological workup when the history suggests a driver.
- The comparison set for aggravation: entrance records, early service records, current exam, side by side.
- The orthotic trial: documented orthotic response (or failure) shows how the foot functions, though DC 5278 does not define any level by relief with arch support.
The weak file is "high arches, foot pain" with no toe, ankle, or fascial findings documented; that exam cannot reach the 10 percent level on the criteria's own text. The DBQ also asks about scars from the condition or its treatment, which are documented on a separate skin questionnaire. The C&P exam prep tool walks through what to bring.
Why VA denies pes cavus claims
Pes cavus claims fare about like the average claim at the Board. Across 388 decided Board rulings on pes cavus from 2021 to 2026, 25.8% were granted, 30.7% denied and 43.6% remanded. That grant rate is 1.1 points above the Board-wide 24.7 percent. Service connection appeals were more common than appeals for a higher rating, and the two were granted at about the same rate; the Board section below breaks the results down by what the appeal asked for.
Too few pes cavus service connection claims were denied for a reliable breakdown of denial reasons, but the evidence gaps behind denials and low ratings are predictable.
Section 4.57 ignored. The claim asserts onset in service even though the condition pre-existed, or alleges aggravation without trauma or other definite evidence of it.
No in-service record of change. An aggravation theory with no in-service treatment, profiles or findings, so nothing shows the foot got worse during service.
Undocumented anatomy. Toe posture, dorsiflexion, fascial length, and callosities unrecorded, so the levels above slight are out of reach.
The toe double-count. Hammer toes separately rated on a foot that already holds a claw-foot rating, denied on the same-foot bar.
A weak secondary opinion. The opinion names a neurological condition but never explains how it changed the foot, or it skips aggravation.
The ignored driver. A progressive cavus foot with no neurological workup, so the secondary lane (and, more importantly, the underlying condition) is never found.
When the Board sends a pes cavus claim back instead of deciding it, the most common reason by a wide margin is an inadequate VA exam or opinion. The Board section below shows how often each remand reason came up and how these appeals have gone since 1992.
Questions veterans ask about pes cavus
Is pes cavus a VA disability?
Yes, when it is service connected. VA rates acquired pes cavus (claw foot) under Diagnostic Code 5278 in 38 CFR 4.71a at 0, 10, 20, 30 or 50 percent, depending on the anatomical findings and whether one foot or both are affected. Because 38 CFR 4.57 calls it a typically congenital or juvenile disease, service connection usually turns on trauma or aggravation in service.
Can high arches that existed before service be service connected?
Yes, by aggravation. If pes cavus was not noted on your entrance exam, VA must show by clear and unmistakable evidence that it existed before service and was not aggravated by service. If it was noted, VA presumes aggravation when it got worse during service, unless clear and unmistakable evidence shows the worsening was natural progress.
What is the highest VA rating for pes cavus?
Fifty percent, for both feet with marked contraction of the plantar fascia with dropped forefoot, all toes hammer toes, very painful callosities and marked varus deformity. The same findings in one foot rate 30 percent.
Can I get separate ratings for pes cavus and hammer toes?
Not on the same foot. DC 5282 pays its 10 percent for hammer toes of all toes on one foot only without claw foot, and DC 5281 says hallux rigidus is not to be combined with claw foot ratings. The pes cavus criteria already count toe deformity at the two top levels.
Does the bilateral factor apply to a bilateral pes cavus rating?
Only sometimes. DC 5278 gives one evaluation for both feet, and VA's manual adds the bilateral factor to it only when you also have another independently ratable condition of one of your legs, or of both arms.
Can pes cavus cause other conditions VA will rate?
Yes, if the medical evidence links them. Cavus feet overload the forefoot and the outside of the ankle, so metatarsalgia, ankle instability and sprains are recognized associations. Each needs its own diagnosis and a medical opinion that explains how the pes cavus caused or worsened it.
Bottom Line
Pes cavus is a four-level anatomical schedule that reaches 50 percent for the full bilateral picture, with the same amounts as flat feet. The level comes from the documented anatomy. Service connection comes first: § 4.57 requires trauma or other definite evidence of aggravation for the typically congenital or juvenile disease it describes, the presumptions of soundness and aggravation decide who has to prove what, and an acquired neurological deformity may support a secondary theory. Keep the express same-foot limits straight and avoid counting the same manifestations under multiple codes.
Related Conditions
Pes cavus is the high-arch pole of the arch spectrum, opposite flat feet. Its load-bearing partners are metatarsalgia and Morton's neuroma (the forefoot it overloads) and plantar fasciitis (the fascia it shortens), with the ankle as its instability neighbor. Neurological primaries live at peripheral neuropathy. Code references: /va-codes/5276 for the mirror and /va-codes/5284 for the catch-all neighbor. The secondary conditions tool maps the chains, and the combined rating calculator runs the stacked-foot math.
Methodology and Limitations
- Data source: Rating criteria quoted from the current eCFR text of 38 CFR § 4.71a, DC 5278, with neighbor codes 5269, 5276, 5279, 5281 and 5282 for the same-foot analysis; pes cavus service connection guidance from § 4.57; the presumption of soundness from § 3.304(b); aggravation from § 3.306; secondary service connection from § 3.310; pyramiding from § 4.14; the bilateral factor from § 4.26. Criteria checked against the eCFR current text on 2026-10-06. The congenital disease rule is VAOPGCPREC 82-90. VA's general foot rule is M21-1 V.iii.1.B.5.c and the bilateral factor rule is M21-1 V.iv.1.C.4.b, both read on 2026-10-06. The exam form is VA's Foot Conditions, Including Flatfoot (Pes Planus) DBQ (updated 2024-09-03). Medical statements are from Seaman, "Pes Cavus," StatPearls (2026); Eleswarapu, "Evaluating the Cavus Foot," Pediatric Annals (2016); Akoh, "Clinical Examination and Radiographic Assessment of the Cavus Foot," Foot and Ankle Clinics (2019); Visser, "The Subtle Cavovarus Foot Deformity: The Nonneurologic Form of Cavus Foot Deformity," Clinics in Podiatric Medicine and Surgery (2021); and Simkin, "Combined effect of foot arch structure and an orthotic device on stress fractures," Foot and Ankle (1989).
- Board statistics: Board figures come from Claim Raven's read of 510,968 Board decisions from 2021 to 2026, which contain 1,376,193 rulings. Of 423 Board rulings on pes cavus, 388 were decided (granted, denied or remanded); dismissed, withdrawn and moot rulings are excluded from the shares. The count covers rulings that name pes cavus or claw foot. Board rulings reflect appeals, not every claim.
- Limitations:
- M21-1 is VA's adjudication manual. The Board is not bound by Department manuals (38 CFR § 20.105), so a Board decision can apply the regulations differently.
- Level assignment is an examiner's anatomical judgment on the day, and progression documentation over time carries more weight than any single exam.
- Whether worsening exceeds natural progression is a medical-opinion question decided on the individual record, not by this page.
- The downstream associations (metatarsalgia, ankle instability, stress fractures) are recognized biomechanical relationships, not certainties for any individual.
- These observations reflect the regulatory text and claim patterns, not legal or medical advice for a specific case.
