Skip to main content
Menu

Conditions Rotator Cuff Injury

Rotator Cuff VA Rating

Written and reviewed by Landon · Updated October 6, 2026

There is no rotator cuff diagnostic code. A cuff tear can be rated four different ways, and the code VA picks decides whether the answer is 10 percent or 50.

Board of Veterans' Appeals: 24.8% granted across 2,391 decided Board rulings on Rotator Cuff Injury, 2021 to 2026. What this number means

Ask Raven about Rotator Cuff Injury

Answers grounded in VA rules and Board decisions. Free to start.

How VA rates Rotator Cuff Injury

DC 5201: Shoulder. Limitation of Arm Motion

DC 5201 rating criteria and monthly pay
RatingWhat VA looks forMonthly pay (2026, veteran alone)Calculator
20%At shoulder level (flexion and/or abduction limited to 90 degrees), major or minor arm; midway between side and shoulder level (flexion and/or abduction limited to 45 degrees), minor arm$356.66Try it
30%Midway between side and shoulder level (flexion and/or abduction limited to 45 degrees), major arm; flexion and/or abduction limited to 25 degrees from side, minor arm$552.47Try it
40%Flexion and/or abduction limited to 25 degrees from side, major arm$795.84Try it

Ratings differ for the major (dominant) and minor arm. Normal shoulder flexion and abduction are each 0 to 180 degrees (38 CFR § 4.71, Plate I).

DC 5200: Scapulohumeral Articulation. Ankylosis

DC 5200 rating criteria and monthly pay
RatingWhat VA looks forMonthly pay (2026, veteran alone)Calculator
20%Favorable, abduction to 60 degrees, can reach mouth and head (minor arm)$356.66Try it
30%Favorable, abduction to 60 degrees, can reach mouth and head (major arm); intermediate between favorable and unfavorable (minor arm)$552.47Try it
40%Intermediate between favorable and unfavorable (major arm); unfavorable, abduction limited to 25 degrees from side (minor arm)$795.84Try it
50%Unfavorable, abduction limited to 25 degrees from side (major arm)$1,132.90Try it

Ratings differ for the major (dominant) and minor arm. The scapula and humerus move as one piece.

Monthly pay is the basic amount for a veteran alone at that overall rating. Separate ratings combine under VA rules; the payments do not add together. Combine your ratings in the calculator or read the VA compensation rates (opens in a new tab).

Criteria checked against 38 CFR Part 4 (eCFR) as of 2026-07-01. 38 CFR § 4.71a explained (official text (opens in a new tab)).

VA forms for Rotator Cuff Injury

A Disability Benefits Questionnaire (DBQ) is a VA form your clinician uses to document your condition and its effects.

Preparing a Rotator Cuff Injury claim?

Check your evidence or draft your lay statement before you read the full Board breakdown.

On this page
  1. TL;DR
  2. Rotator cuff VA rating criteria (DC 5201 and the other codes)
    1. DC 5201: limitation of arm motion
    2. DC 5304: muscle group IV
    3. DC 5200: ankylosis of the shoulder
    4. Tendinopathy, bursitis and arthritis (DC 5024, DC 5019, DC 5003)
    5. Shoulder replacement (DC 5051)
    6. Choosing the code without pyramiding
  3. The dominant arm: major and minor columns
  4. Pain, flare-ups and DeLuca: the exam math
  5. Rotator cuff surgery: the temporary 100 percent and re-rating
  6. How to prove a rotator cuff tear is service connected
    1. Direct service connection
    2. Rotator cuff tear secondary to another service-connected condition
  7. The rotator cuff C&P exam
  8. Why VA denies rotator cuff claims
  9. Questions veterans ask about rotator cuff tears
    1. What is the VA rating for a rotator cuff tear?
    2. What is the highest VA rating for a rotator cuff injury?
    3. Does the dominant arm get a higher rotator cuff rating?
    4. Can I get a temporary 100 percent rating after rotator cuff surgery?
    5. Can a rotator cuff tear be secondary to another service-connected condition?
    6. Can I get a rotator cuff rating for both shoulders?
  10. Bottom Line
  11. Related Conditions

Search the rating schedule for "rotator cuff" and you will not find it. Cuff tears, tendinopathy, and impingement are rated through the shoulder codes in 38 CFR § 4.71a and the muscle-injury schedule in § 4.73: limitation of arm motion (DC 5201), ankylosis of the shoulder joint (DC 5200), muscle group IV injury (DC 5304), and, when tendinopathy, bursitis, or arthritis is the diagnosis, the degenerative-arthritis framework with its painful-motion minimums. The rater's job is to pick the code that yields the highest justified evaluation without double-counting. Your job is to make sure the record supports the most favorable frame.

The most common frame is DC 5201, limitation of motion of the arm, and it is strictly geometric: flexion or abduction limited to shoulder level (90 degrees) rates 20 percent on either arm; midway between side and shoulder level (45 degrees) rates 30 on the dominant arm or 20 on the other; limited to 25 degrees from the side rates 40 dominant or 30 non-dominant. The goniometer reading at the C&P exam maps directly to those numbers, which is why the exam-day measurement, plus the pain and flare-up evidence that puts it in context, decides most cuff claims.

This page covers the rotator cuff VA rating criteria, the dominant arm, what painful motion and flare-ups add, the temporary 100 percent after surgery, how to prove service connection, the C&P exam, and why VA denies rotator cuff claims. For the full shoulder rating chart, including instability, labral tears, and the clavicle, see the shoulder page.


TL;DR

  • Rotator cuff pathology has no dedicated code. It is rated on limitation of arm motion (DC 5201), ankylosis (DC 5200), muscle group IV injury (DC 5304), or the arthritis framework (DC 5024 for tendinopathy, DC 5019 for bursitis, DC 5003 for arthritis), whichever is most favorable without pyramiding.
  • DC 5201: 20%/20% at shoulder level (90 degrees), 30%/20% at 45 degrees, 40%/30% at 25 degrees from the side, dominant versus non-dominant arm.
  • DC 5304 (the cuff's own muscle group): severe 30%/20%, moderately severe 20%/20%, moderate 10%/10%, slight 0%. A 40/30 severe level belongs to muscle group III (DC 5303), not group IV.
  • Even with full exam-day motion, painful motion with joint pathology supports at least the minimum compensable rating under 38 CFR § 4.59, and flare-ups can push the functional evaluation higher.
  • Surgery may support a temporary 100 percent under 38 CFR § 4.30 only when treatment of a service-connected disability meets the rule's convalescence, severe-residual, or immobilization requirements. The shoulder is then evaluated on residuals. A total shoulder replacement moves the rating to DC 5051.
  • Common service-connection routes: direct from an in-service injury or repetitive overhead load, and secondary to a service-connected condition under 38 CFR § 3.310.
  • Across 2,391 decided Board rulings on rotator cuff injuries from 2021 to 2026, 24.8% were granted, 32.5% denied and 42.7% remanded. A ruling is one issue the Board decided in one decision; one decision often rules on several issues. That grant rate is 0.1 points above the Board-wide 24.7 percent. Rating appeals were granted far less often than service connection claims; the Board section below shows results by what the appeal asked for.

Rotator cuff VA rating criteria (DC 5201 and the other codes)

DC 5201: limitation of arm motion

DC 5201 is the workhorse. The cuff's job is to stabilize the shoulder and power flexion, abduction, and rotation, so a torn or tendinopathic cuff shows up as lost motion, and the code prices that loss in three steps.

Flexion and/or abduction limited toDominant armNon-dominant arm
25 degrees from the side40%30%
Midway between side and shoulder level (45 degrees)30%20%
Shoulder level (90 degrees)20%20%

DC 5201 pays only at 90 degrees or worse. Normal flexion and abduction on VA's shoulder exam form are 180 degrees each, so an arm that rises well above shoulder level is noncompensable under this code, which is where the painful-motion minimum and the other frames come in. The DC 5201 reference gives the schedule text.

DC 5304: muscle group IV

Muscle group IV holds the rotator cuff muscles in the muscle-injury schedule: the supraspinatus, infraspinatus and teres minor, subscapularis, and coracobrachialis, which hold the head of the humerus in the socket and rotate the arm. The current text rates severe 30% dominant or 20% non-dominant, moderately severe 20% either arm, moderate 10% either arm, and slight 0%. The 40/30 severe level belongs to muscle group III (DC 5303, the deltoid and the clavicular part of the pectoralis major), one group up the schedule; for the cuff's own group, 30/20 is the ceiling.

There is a catch. Note (2) to § 4.73 says the slight through severe levels are set by the criteria in § 4.56, and those criteria are written around wounds: through-and-through or deep penetrating wounds, missile tracks, debridement, and open fractures. In my read of the schedule, DC 5304 fits a cuff damaged by that kind of wound better than a tear from overuse or a fall, where the motion code and the tendinopathy code are the more natural fits. The muscle injuries DBQ is the exam form for this code.

DC 5200: ankylosis of the shoulder

DC 5200 is for the shoulder that has effectively frozen, with the scapula and humerus moving as one piece. Favorable ankylosis (abduction to 60 degrees, can reach mouth and head) rates 30 dominant or 20 non-dominant; intermediate 40/30; unfavorable (abduction limited to 25 degrees from the side) 50/40. This is the frame for the most severe mechanical loss, post-surgical or post-traumatic. The DC 5200 reference has the text.

Tendinopathy, bursitis and arthritis (DC 5024, DC 5019, DC 5003)

Rotator cuff tendinopathy has a code: DC 5024 covers tenosynovitis, tendinitis, tendinosis or tendinopathy, and DC 5019 covers bursitis. The note to DCs 5013 through 5024 says to evaluate them "as degenerative arthritis, based on limitation of motion of affected parts." Degenerative arthritis established by X-ray is rated on limitation of motion; when that limitation is noncompensable under the joint code but objectively confirmed (by findings such as swelling, muscle spasm, or satisfactory evidence of painful motion), DC 5003 provides a 10 percent evaluation for the affected major joint, and § 4.45 counts the shoulder as a major joint. Section 4.59 separately recognizes actually painful, unstable, or malaligned joints as entitled to at least the minimum compensable rating for the joint. The diagnosis and findings determine which route applies; pain alone does not assign a percentage without the right rating framework.

Shoulder replacement (DC 5051)

An irreparable cuff tear, or a cuff tear with arthritis, is sometimes treated with a reverse total shoulder replacement; a 2026 study in the Journal of Shoulder and Elbow Arthroplasty (Rohl) compared outcomes for that surgery across irreparable cuff tears, cuff tears with arthritis, and osteoarthritis. Once the joint is replaced, DC 5051 controls: 100 percent for one year following implantation (starting after the one-month § 4.30 total rating), then 60 percent dominant or 50 non-dominant for chronic residuals of severe painful motion or weakness, intermediate residuals rated by analogy to DC 5200 and DC 5203, and a minimum of 30 dominant or 20 non-dominant. No other § 4.71a rating can be added for that joint unless the schedule directs it.

Choosing the code without pyramiding

Across all of these, the rater assigns the code producing the highest justified evaluation, and the same disability cannot be rated twice under different codes (38 CFR § 4.14). Section 4.55(c) also generally bars a separate muscle-group rating for muscles acting on an ankylosed joint. DC 5202 (other impairment of the humerus) sits at the far end for structural bone loss and recurrent dislocation, with flail shoulder at 80 percent on the dominant arm; it is mentioned here for completeness rather than as a common cuff frame.


The dominant arm: major and minor columns

At the higher levels of every shoulder code above, the dominant arm rates up to 10 points more than the other arm. Under 38 CFR § 4.69, handedness is determined by the evidence of record or by testing on the VA exam, only one hand is considered dominant, and for an ambidextrous veteran the injured hand, or the more severely injured one, is treated as dominant. VA's shoulder exam form asks the examiner to record the dominant hand at the top. If the record gets it wrong, the rating can come out 10 points low at the 30 and 40 percent levels of DC 5201.


Pain, flare-ups and DeLuca: the exam math

The DC 5201 table makes the exam look mechanical, and mostly it is: the goniometer reads flexion and abduction, and the reading maps to a percentage. Three things bend the raw reading.

Pain on use. Under the functional-loss rules (§ 4.40, § 4.45, § 4.59) and DeLuca v. Brown, 8 Vet. App. 202 (1995), pain, weakness, fatigability, and incoordination that limit the shoulder's actual use count, not just the static number. Section 4.40 says "a part which becomes painful on use must be regarded as seriously disabled," and that pain must be "supported by adequate pathology and evidenced by the visible behavior of the claimant undertaking the motion." A veteran who reaches well above shoulder level once but cannot use the arm overhead repeatedly, or who guards through the range, presents a functional limit the raw degree number understates. The examiner is supposed to record where pain begins and what it costs. Section 4.59 also says the joint should be tested for pain on active and passive motion and in weight-bearing and nonweight-bearing, and the Court held in Correia v. McDonald, 28 Vet. App. 158 (2016), that an exam missing that testing is inadequate.

Flare-ups. Shoulders flare after heavy use, in cold weather, or for days at a time. In Sharp v. Shulkin (2017), a shoulder case, the Court held that the examiner has to estimate the additional loss during flare-ups, using the veteran's own account when the exam is not done during a flare, or explain why an estimate is not feasible. The evidence is your own documented history: what triggers flares, how long they last, and what the arm cannot do during one.

Weakness and instability. Section 4.40 says "weakness is as important as limitation of motion." Repeated dislocations are rated under DC 5202's recurrent dislocation levels: 20 percent for infrequent episodes with guarding of movement only at shoulder level, and 30 percent dominant or 20 non-dominant for frequent episodes with guarding of all arm movements. A cuff that tests at 90 degrees of motion but cannot hold a load is not a normal shoulder.


Rotator cuff surgery: the temporary 100 percent and re-rating

A rotator cuff repair does not automatically create a temporary 100 percent rating. Under 38 CFR § 4.30, treatment of a service-connected disability must result in surgery requiring at least one month of convalescence, surgery with severe postoperative residuals such as therapeutic immobilization of a major joint, or immobilization by cast without surgery. The total rating runs from the date of admission or outpatient treatment for 1, 2, or 3 months from the first day of the month after discharge, and it can be extended. It is then followed by the appropriate schedular evaluation of residual motion, strength, pain, and instability. Post-surgical records should document both the recovery period and the residual disability.


How to prove a rotator cuff tear is service connected

Direct service connection

Direct service connection covers a cuff injured in service: overhead lifting, ruck weight on shoulder straps, weapons maintenance, ammunition handling, parachute landings, falls, and repetitive overhead work. A 2025 study of active-duty Army soldiers in the American Journal of Preventive Medicine (Kusumpa) found that soldiers with a history of shoulder impingement had about two and a half times the hazard of a later rotator cuff tear compared with soldiers without one. The file needs in-service shoulder complaints or injury, a current diagnosis, and a nexus opinion.

Imaging alone does not carry the nexus. A 2026 population study in JAMA Internal Medicine (Ibounig) found rotator cuff changes on MRI in nearly all adults aged 41 to 76, in shoulders with and without symptoms, and concluded they often reflect normal age-related change. That is why an examiner may attribute a tear to age-related wear, and why the in-service record, the history of symptoms since service, and a reasoned opinion matter more than the MRI report.

Rotator cuff tear secondary to another service-connected condition

Secondary service connection under 38 CFR § 3.310 covers a cuff condition caused by a service-connected disability, such as years of overloading one shoulder because the other arm, elbow, or wrist is service-connected. These are theories, and each needs a medical opinion that explains the mechanism for your case. It also covers aggravation: a cuff condition aggravated by your service-connected disability, meaning it would be less severe but for that disability. An opinion that addresses only causation and skips aggravation is inadequate (El-Amin v. Shinseki, 26 Vet. App. 136 (2013)).

Among the rotator cuff service connection rulings the Board decided from 2021 to 2026, direct claims far outnumbered secondary ones, and the two were granted at similar rates; the Board section below shows both.


The rotator cuff C&P exam

VA's shoulder and arm exam form is mostly a measurement exercise, and it has a section just for the rotator cuff. A complete exam captures these findings.

  • Active and passive flexion, abduction, and internal and external rotation with a goniometer, against normal endpoints of 180, 180, 90, and 90 degrees, and where pain starts in each arc.
  • Pain on active and passive motion and in weight-bearing and nonweight-bearing, with the opposite shoulder tested when possible.
  • Repetitive-use testing with at least three repetitions, and an estimate in degrees of the loss after repeated use over time and during flare-ups.
  • The rotator cuff tests: the Hawkins impingement test, the empty can test, the external rotation (infraspinatus) strength test, and the lift-off (subscapularis) test.
  • Instability, dislocation, or labral findings, and any ankylosis.
  • The dominant hand, any surgery and its residuals, and the functional impact on work tasks such as lifting.

What strengthens the file is imaging that shows the tear or tendinopathy, motion documented over time rather than once, a flare description in your own words that stays consistent across statements and records, and post-surgical residual findings when there was surgery. What weakens it is a single pain-free exam day presented as the whole story, or a diagnosis of "shoulder pain" with no structural characterization. The C&P exam prep checklist and the symptom tracker help you bring that history to the exam.


Why VA denies rotator cuff claims

Rotator cuff claims land close to the Board average. Across 2,391 decided Board rulings on rotator cuff injuries from 2021 to 2026, 24.8% were granted, 32.5% denied and 42.7% remanded, a grant rate 0.1 points above the Board-wide 24.7 percent. Rating appeals outnumbered service connection appeals and were granted far less often.

When the Board denied service connection for a rotator cuff condition, the most common reason by far was a missing link to service, ahead of no documented in-service injury or event. The patterns behind those denials, and behind ratings that come in low, repeat.

No nexus, or the tear blamed on age. The MRI shows a tear, but no opinion ties it to service, or the examiner calls it age-related wear. Cuff changes on MRI are common in middle age with or without symptoms, so the opinion has to rest on the in-service history and the course since, not the image.

No in-service injury on record. Service treatment records show no shoulder complaint, and the claim rests on memory. Lay statements about overhead work, falls, or early impingement help fill that gap; impingement documented in service matters because it is associated with later tears.

A secondary opinion that skips aggravation. When the cuff is claimed as secondary, a negative opinion that addresses only causation and never asks whether the service-connected condition made the cuff worse is inadequate.

The pain-free exam day. Full motion demonstrated once is used to justify 0 percent, with no flare-up estimate and no pain-on-use findings developed.

Wrong code, lower number. The claim is evaluated on the muscle schedule's moderate 10 percent when the motion picture supports DC 5201's 20, or the reverse. The highest-justified-evaluation principle exists to fix this, but only when the record supports the better frame.

Dominance recorded wrong, or surgery left undocumented. The dominant and non-dominant columns differ by up to 10 points per level, and a repair with no residual measurements leaves the re-rating to the thinnest record.

When the Board sends a rotator cuff appeal back instead of deciding it, the most common reason is an inadequate VA exam or opinion, followed by records VA still needed to get. A favorable medical opinion the Board found persuasive nearly always ended in a grant, and an opinion against the claim did not. The Board section below shows how often each denial and remand reason came up, and what the Board did with medical opinions.


Questions veterans ask about rotator cuff tears

What is the VA rating for a rotator cuff tear?

Most rotator cuff tears are rated on limitation of arm motion under DC 5201: 20 percent when the arm is limited to shoulder level, 30 percent dominant or 20 non-dominant at 45 degrees, and 40 percent dominant or 30 non-dominant at 25 degrees from the side. A cuff with better motion may still get 10 percent under the tendinopathy and arthritis codes when the lost motion is objectively confirmed, for example by painful motion.

What is the highest VA rating for a rotator cuff injury?

Under the motion code, 40 percent on the dominant arm. Unfavorable ankylosis of the dominant shoulder under DC 5200 rates 50 percent. After a total shoulder replacement, DC 5051 assigns 100 percent for one year, then at least 30 percent on the dominant arm and up to 60 percent for severe chronic residuals.

Does the dominant arm get a higher rotator cuff rating?

Yes, at the higher levels. Under DC 5201, the dominant arm rates 30 percent at 45 degrees and 40 percent at 25 degrees from the side, against 20 and 30 percent for the other arm; at shoulder level both arms rate 20 percent. Under 38 CFR 4.69, only one hand is treated as dominant.

Can I get a temporary 100 percent rating after rotator cuff surgery?

Yes, if the surgery treated a service-connected shoulder and required at least one month of convalescence, left severe postoperative residuals such as immobilization of the joint, or the shoulder was immobilized by cast. Under 38 CFR 4.30 the total rating lasts 1 to 3 months after discharge and can be extended, then the shoulder is rated on its residuals.

Can a rotator cuff tear be secondary to another service-connected condition?

Yes, under 38 CFR 3.310, if a medical opinion explains how a service-connected condition caused the cuff problem or made it worse, such as years of overloading one shoulder because of a service-connected injury on the other side. The opinion has to address aggravation, not only causation.

Can I get a rotator cuff rating for both shoulders?

Yes. Each shoulder is rated on its own, with only one arm treated as dominant. When both shoulders are rated at least 10 percent, the bilateral factor in 38 CFR 4.26 adds 10 percent of their combined value before they combine with your other ratings.


Bottom Line

A rotator cuff rating is a routing decision before it is a number. Many claims are evaluated on the DC 5201 motion table: 20 percent at shoulder level, up to 40 on the dominant arm at 25 degrees from the side. The tendinopathy and arthritis framework, the cuff's muscle code (DC 5304), the ankylosis code (DC 5200), and the shoulder replacement code (DC 5051) apply when their criteria fit. Pain, flare-ups, and functional loss must be considered with the measured motion. After surgery, a temporary 100 percent applies only when § 4.30's specific requirements are established; otherwise the condition is evaluated on its documented residuals.


The cuff's umbrella is the shoulder page, which covers the joint's other codes (instability, labrum, clavicle, arthritis) and the full shoulder rating chart. Arthritis is the degenerative partner, and the elbow is the downstream neighbor. Code references: /va-codes/5201, /va-codes/5200, and /va-codes/5003; the muscle-group, humerus, and replacement codes (5304, 5202, 5051) are in the eCFR text of §§ 4.73 and 4.71a. The secondary conditions tool maps the overuse chains, and the combined rating calculator runs the shoulder math with the dominant and non-dominant columns.


Methodology and Limitations

  • Data source: Rating criteria paraphrased and quoted from the current eCFR text of 38 CFR § 4.71a (DC 5200, 5201, 5202, 5003, 5019, 5024, 5051), § 4.73 (DC 5303, 5304), § 4.56 (muscle injury levels), § 4.55 (muscle injuries and ankylosed joints), §§ 4.40, 4.45, and 4.59 (functional loss and painful motion), § 4.69 (dominant hand), § 4.30 (convalescence), § 4.14 (pyramiding), § 4.26 (bilateral factor), and § 3.310 (secondary service connection). Regulations re-checked against the eCFR current text on 2026-10-06. Case law from DeLuca v. Brown, 8 Vet. App. 202 (1995), Correia v. McDonald, 28 Vet. App. 158 (2016), Sharp v. Shulkin (2017), and El-Amin v. Shinseki, 26 Vet. App. 136 (2013).
  • Exam form: Exam details (normal endpoints, the rotator cuff tests, pain and repetitive-use testing, flare-up estimates, dominant hand) come from VA's public Shoulder and Arm Conditions disability benefits questionnaire, fetched from benefits.va.gov on 2026-10-06.
  • Medical sources: Kusumpa, "Increased Risk of Rotator Cuff Tear in U.S. Army Soldiers With a History of Prior Shoulder Impingement Syndrome," American Journal of Preventive Medicine (2025). Ibounig, "Incidental Rotator Cuff Abnormalities on Magnetic Resonance Imaging," JAMA Internal Medicine (2026). Rohl, reverse total shoulder arthroplasty outcomes by indication, Journal of Shoulder and Elbow Arthroplasty (2026).
  • Board statistics: Claim Raven's read of 510,968 Board decisions from 2021 to 2026, which contain 1,376,193 rulings, including 2,658 rulings on rotator cuff injuries. Across the 2,391 decided rulings, 24.8% were granted, 32.5% denied and 42.7% remanded; dismissed and withdrawn rulings are excluded. The Board section below the article breaks these out by appeal type, claim theory, medical opinion, and denial and remand reason. These are appealed claims, not your personal odds.
  • Limitations:
  • Which code frame controls a given claim is the rater's determination on the record; this page describes the routing logic, not its application to any claim.
  • Occupational research linking impingement to tear is associational and population-level; it does not establish service connection for any individual.
  • Flare-up evaluation is evidence-dependent; descriptions here are the regulatory framework, not a promised outcome.
  • Selection bias: Board-level patterns reflect cases that appealed. Many rotator cuff claims resolve at the regional office and are not in any Board dataset.
  • These observations reflect the regulatory text, case law, and Board decisions, not legal or medical advice for a specific case.

What Board appeals show for Rotator Cuff Injury

These are outcomes at the Board of Veterans' Appeals, not first-time claims, and not your personal odds. They show where appeals on this issue tend to land.

How appeals on this issue ended

24.8%

granted across 2,391 decided Board rulings on Rotator Cuff Injury, 2021 to 2026.

  • Granted592 24.8%
  • Denied778 32.5%
  • Sent back1,021 42.7%

"Sent back" means remanded: the Board returned the claim to VA for more work instead of deciding it.

When the Board discussed a private medical opinion

Granted or denied rulings where the Board's decision discussed a private medical opinion (184)85.9%

All Rotator Cuff Injury granted or denied rulings (1,370)43.2%

Both rows leave out remands, because the Board weighs this evidence only when it grants or denies. Association, not cause; the Board may simply discuss stronger evidence more.

The full evidence breakdown, with grant rates for every evidence type and language from actual Board decisions, is in Raven Insights, included with every paid plan.

Why the Board denied rotator cuff injury claims

In 159 service connection rulings the Board denied, 2021 to 2026, it found this part of the claim not shown:

  • A link between rotator cuff injury and service (nexus)100.0%
  • An event, injury or exposure in service55.3%
  • A current diagnosis0.0%

A denial can fail more than one part, so the shares can add up to more than 100%.

Why the Board sent rotator cuff injury claims back

Of 1,021 rotator cuff injury rulings the Board remanded, 2021 to 2026:

  • The VA exam or opinion was not adequate66.2%
  • VA still had records to get29.5%
  • The exam was out of date or the condition had worsened10.6%
  • VA had not given an exam6.8%

A remand can ask for records and a new exam at once, so these overlap.

Results by what the appeal asked for

Board rulings on rotator cuff injury, 2021 to 2026, by the question the Board decided. The share is granted out of every decided ruling, remands included.

  • A higher rating11.8% of 1,104
  • Service connection36.1% of 975
  • An earlier effective date31.0% of 200

What the Board did with medical opinions

Service connection rulings on rotator cuff injury the Board granted or denied, 2021 to 2026, by the medical opinion it relied on. The share is granted.

  • It relied on a favorable medical opinion99.6% of 225
  • It found the VA opinion inadequate or gave it less weight89.1% of 119
  • It relied on an opinion against the claim0.0% of 121

All granted or denied rotator cuff injury service connection rulings: 66.8% of 527.

Remands are left out on both sides, because the Board weighs medical opinions only when it grants or denies. Associations, not causes.

Direct, secondary and presumptive claims

Service connection rulings on rotator cuff injury, 2021 to 2026, by how the claim was argued. The share is granted out of every decided ruling, remands included.

  • Direct: it began in service36.8% of 775
  • Secondary: caused or worsened by a service-connected condition33.5% of 200
  • Presumptive: the law presumes the link24.6% of 138

All rotator cuff injury service connection rulings: 36.1% of 975.

A presumptive claim is also counted as direct or secondary.

How rotator cuff injury appeals have gone since 1992

Every Board ruling on rotator cuff injury since 1992, by when it was decided. The share is granted out of every decided ruling.

  • 1992 to 200218.6% of 344
  • 2003 to February 201915.1% of 1,997
  • February 2019 to August 2022 (new appeals system)23.0% of 1,519
  • Since August 2022 (PACT Act)24.2% of 2,132

These rows come from a simpler reading of every decision's order since 1992, so they are a different measure from the 2021 to 2026 figures elsewhere on this page. Issues with unclear outcomes, or with both a decision and a remand, are left out.

Do you need a nexus letter for Rotator Cuff Injury?

A nexus opinion may matter when VA disputes whether this condition is connected to service or to an already service-connected condition.

  • If service connection is already established, the dispute may be about rating severity rather than nexus.
  • If a presumptive rule covers the condition and service, a separate nexus opinion may not be required.
  • If the current diagnosis, event, or medical explanation is missing, locate that evidence before asking a clinician for an opinion.

Do you need a nexus letter for this condition? View Raven Nexus.

Your next step

Get one VA document reviewed free

Upload a decision letter, medical record, exam report or statement. You get findings, source references and suggested next steps.

One free review per verified email. No credit card needed.

Write your personal statement

Describe your symptoms and daily impact, then download your statement. No account required.

Open the free builder

Ask Raven about Rotator Cuff Injury

Ask specific questions about your rotator cuff injury claim and get answers grounded in Board decisions.

Ask a question

Have a VA decision letter? Raven Eye explains it in plain English. Have your VA medical records? Raven Scan looks for conditions you have not claimed.

Grant rates reflect Board outcomes on appealed claims, not initial-claim outcomes. Claim Raven is not legal or medical advice and is not affiliated with the VA.

Veterans Crisis Line: dial 988, then press 1